|
Sunday, October 05, 2008 - 9:24 AM
Louis J. Sheehan, Esquire. Palm readers take note: A team of Canadian psychologists suggests
that part of understanding sexual orientation may be close at hand. http://ljsheehan.blogspot.com The
clue isn't in the bend of the love line or length of the ring finger.
It's in which hand you present to the palmist. The psychologists
combined the results of 20 previous studies, both published and
unpublished, comparing rates of right-handedness in a total of 23,410
homosexual and heterosexual men and women. http://ljsheehan.blogspot.com
The researchers report in the July Psychological Bulletin
that, overall, homosexual adults in the studies were 39 percent more
likely than heterosexuals to use their left hand for more activities.
The rate was even higher among lesbians, who were nearly twice as
likely as heterosexuals to be left- or mixed-handed. Because hand
preference likely has a prenatal origin, the analysis supports the idea
that sexual orientation also has early neurobiological roots, says
Kenneth J. Zucker of the Centre for Addiction and Mental Health in
Toronto and the University of Toronto, an author of the study. The
analysis is notable, too, because it reveals a correlate of
homosexuality—in this case handedness—that's common to both gay men and
lesbians. Many hypotheses posit separate explanations for the sexual
preference of each group. Although the team found a significant
correlation, the size of the effect was small, prompting some
researchers to downplay the sexuality-southpaw link. The team is
"drawing a weak connection between one poorly understood phenomenon and
another poorly understood phenomenon," says Simon LeVay, a Los Angeles
neuroscientist who in 1991 discovered structural differences in brain
anatomy between gay and heterosexual men. A widely reported paper in the March 30 Nature
by a research team led by psychologist S. Marc Breedlove at the
University of California, Berkeley suggested a link between a similar
prenatal event and sexual orientation. The team found that lesbians
had, on average, a longer ring finger than index finger, a pattern more
often found in men and influenced by prenatal androgen exposure. The
same study determined that homosexual men were more likely than
heterosexual men to have several older brothers, whose gestation
increases androgen levels in the uterine environment for subsequent
births. The authors of the new metanalysis argue against this
androgen-exposure hypothesis. Although men are slightly better
represented among left-handers than women, the researchers argue that
high levels of androgens have not been linked to left-handedness in
boys and are actually associated with right-handedness in girls.
Instead, the researchers suggest the connection between handedness and
sexual orientation may indicate developmental instability—the degree to
which a fetus is exposed to environmental stressors, such as
pollutants—or genetic mutations. http://ljsheehan.blogspot.com
It's too early to make such a
conclusion, says J. Michael Bailey, a psychologist at Northwestern
University in Evanston, Ill. "This is really the first finding that
would point in that direction, and that's not the only direction to
point," he says. Breedlove agrees, accusing the Canadians of
fatal vagueness. "What cellular process is unstable here?" he asks.
"Cell death, neurogenesis, synapse elimination?" Because the theory
carries such explosive political implications—homosexuality as
"defect"—Breedlove finds its shortcomings disquieting. Zucker
readily acknowledges that an as-yet-unidentified variable may be
responsible for the connection found by his team. "I'm satisfied with
the fact that the metanalysis says there really is an empirical
phenomenon to be explained," he says, "and in research in sexual
orientation, that's an advance." Louis J. Sheehan, Esquire
|